A decade later, Santa Ana dad still fights for his son’s return from Japan

Posted by Jeremy Morley | Aug 31, 2017 | 0 Comments

By SUSAN CHRISTIAN GOULDING | [email protected] | Orange County Register

In an alternate life, Keisuke Collins would have started high school last week as a freshman at Foothill High. But in reality, Keisuke lives an ocean away from Orange County and from the father who misses him.

In the wake of a bitter divorce, Collins' ex-wife, Reiko, spirited their then-5-year-old to her native Japan. Officials there have made “zero attempt” to reunite father and son, he said.

Randy Collins, 56, has not spoken with the boy throughout his school career. “Not a day goes by that he isn't on my mind,” said the Santa Ana resident.

Collins and dozens of other parents in similar situations around the country have bonded over their common cause. They share a passion for testifying before congressional hearings and for imploring politicians to take action. They share a national organization, Bring Abducted Children Home – which counts about 400 children living in Japan without access to their American parents. Mostly, however, they share heartache.

Collins' ex-wife could not be reached for comment. The Orange County attorney who represented her in the divorce did not return requests for comment.

The last time Collins saw Keisuke was June 2008, when they spent a jam-packed Father's Day together. They attended church, visited the Discovery Cube, grabbed a bite for lunch and played at the beach. Then Collins took the child back to his mom, expecting to see him again the following night.

But she phoned the next afternoon and said Keisuke was under the weather. Little did Collins realize she had placed the call from the Seattle airport on her way to Japan, ignoring a court order that forbade her from leaving the country with their child, he said.

“She was already gone,” said Collins, who works in mortgage lending. Thus began an expensive and fruitless legal effort to get Keisuke back.

That mission included a 2015 trip to Japan with his best friend since Westminster High School, Ta'alolo Puni Pa'u.

“My passport was flagged at the airport,” Collins said. “Police notified Reiko and kept tabs on me.”

Nine days later, he decamped without so much as a glimpse of his son.

“I was bawling my eyes out,” Collins said.

“He started out so hopeful that he at least would get to see Keisuke, but left in utter despair,” said Pa'u, a hotel executive in Dallas.

New York attorney Jeremy Morley, an expert in international family law, has represented numerous parents in Collins' shoes. Japan, he said, takes a hands-off approach in custody disputes even when both parents are Japanese.

“Left-behind American parents have every reason to be mad at Japan,” Morley said. “Yet it's a reflection of serious cultural differences, not malice. Japanese society regards the law as an instrument that should not interfere with the privacy of family life.”

U.S. Navy Captain Paul Toland, 50, knows too well that anger, frustration and pain.

Toland met his wife, Etsuko, while stationed in Japan. The couple welcomed daughter, Erika, in 2002.

Etsuko experienced postpartum depression and went with the baby to her mom's home for what Toland assumed would be a brief visit. Instead, his wife cut off communication with him. Japanese courts offered no assistance, he said.

“If I'd had even an inkling that a U.S. ally could actually separate an American father from his child, I would never have let Erika out of my sight,” Toland said.

Etsuko committed suicide in 2007. Even after her death, Toland could not gain custody of his daughter. A court granted guardianship to Erika's grandmother, who continued to block contact.

“Japan's entire family law system is broken,” Toland said. “In a divorce, there is no joint custody. One parent — whoever happens to have possession of the child at that time — gets 100 percent parental rights. So in a sense, my daughter was orphaned when her mother died.”

Children usually stay with the mother after a divorce, Morley said, and the father has little involvement.

“A father who demands custody rights is viewed as someone disturbing family peace,” he said.

In 2014, Japan belatedly signed the 1980 Hague treaty on international child abduction. Although a positive step, Toland said, Japan continues to grant full rights to one parent regardless.

“For anything to change, Japan's laws must change,” said Toland, now stationed in Hawaii. “Yes, there have been voluntary returns. But not one child has ever been returned from Japan through legal channels.”

U.S. Congressman Chris Smith of New Jersey champions the issue of cross-border child abduction, which he calls “child abuse.” He argues that the United States should be more assertive with Japan, “a flagrant violator.”

“When is enough, enough?” Smith said in an email. “What we need is a change in the culture of the U.S. State Department, which too often rewards its foreign service officers for appeasing countries in the name of maintaining ‘harmonious' relations. The U.S. must show it means business when it comes to the return of our abducted children.”

The longtime congressman, who for years has worked with Bring Abducted Children Home, praises Collins as “an inspiration.”

“He is tireless and will never stop fighting,” Smith said.

Indeed, Collins promised, he “will never give up.”
“Keisuke is my son, my only child,” he said.

About the Author

Jeremy Morley

Jeremy D. Morley was admitted to the New York Bar in 1975 and concentrates on international family law. His firm works with clients around the world from its New York office, with a global network of local counsel. Mr. Morley is the author of "International Family Law Practice,...


There are no comments for this post. Be the first and Add your Comment below.

Leave a Comment

Providing wise and experienced legal counsel to international families for many years

Aenean lacinia bibendum nulla sed consectetur. Donec sed odio dui. Maecenas sed diam eget risus varius blandit sit amet non magna. Nulla vitae elit libero, a pharetra augue. Curabitur blandit tempus porttitor. Morbi leo risus, porta ac consectetur ac, vestibulum at eros. Cras justo odio, dapibus ac facilisis in, egestas.